Skip to content

Selection guides

Soft starter or VFD? How to choose the right motor starting solution

Both limit starting current, but only a VFD controls speed. A comparison of soft starters and frequency inverters by starting behaviour, speed control, energy saving and typical applications.

Soft starter or VFD? How to choose the right motor starting solution

Starting a motor direct-on-line draws 6 to 7 times its rated current and applies a torque shock to the machine. Both soft starters and frequency inverters (VFDs) avoid this, but they work differently and suit different jobs.

How each one works

Soft starter. Hailing soft starters use a DSP controller and SCR (thyristor) phase-angle control to raise the motor voltage gradually during start and lower it during stop. The motor still runs at the supply frequency, so once started it runs at full speed. Typical starting modes include current limit, voltage ramp, kick start plus current limit or voltage ramp, current ramp and dual closed-loop control; stopping is by voltage ramp or freewheel.

Frequency inverter. A VFD rectifies the supply and generates a new output of variable frequency and voltage. It starts the motor from near zero speed at low current and can hold any speed in between, with full torque available at low speed in vector control.

Comparison

Soft starterFrequency inverter
Starting currentReduced, set by the starting mode and current limitLow, close to the load current
Speed controlNo; full speed after startYes, continuous
Energy saving on fans and pumpsOnly during startingLarge savings at reduced flow
BrakingSoft stop or freewheelControlled deceleration, braking resistor for fast stops
Harmonics while runningUsually bypassed at full speedRectifier harmonics; reactors or filters may be needed
Cost and size at high powerLowerHigher

Which one to choose

  • Choose a soft starter when the motor runs at constant speed and the aim is to cut starting current and mechanical shock: crushers, mixers, conveyors started once and run continuously, compressors and pumps without flow control.
  • Choose a VFD when speed, flow or pressure must be controlled, when energy saving at partial load matters, or when the process needs precise acceleration, positioning or torque: fans, constant-pressure water supply, machine tools, hoists and extruders.
  • For a constant-speed motor on a weak supply, a soft starter is often the economical answer. If the duty may later need speed control, a VFD avoids a second investment.

Hailing options

Hailing motor soft starters cover AC 50 Hz supplies of about 220 V, 400 V, 660 V and 1140 V from 5.5 to 600 kW, with RS485/Modbus communication for up to 64 starters on one bus. For speed control see the industrial frequency inverters. Read more in the motor starting solution.

SEND INQUIRY NOW

Call or WeChat us directly, or tell us your motor, supply, PV array or application requirements below and we will reply with a product recommendation.

Headquarters · China

Qingdao Hailing Electric Co., Ltd.

CallEmail
Pakistan Company

VICTORY ENERGY TECHNOLOGIES (PVT) LIMITED

Industrial control room
Qingdao Hailing Electric Co., Ltd.No. 5 Yuanzhong Road, Jiaobei, Jiaozhou, Qingdao, China